Meal Replacement Ingredients: 4 to Avoid And 2 to Look For
Meal Replacement Ingredients: 4 to Avoid And 2 to Look For
Uncover the hidden risks and potential benefits in meal replacement drinks, exploring what to avoid and what to embrace for healthier choices.
The concept of replacing food is already a bit suspicious, but many meal replacement drink manufacturers go quite a bit further, claiming that their product is actually "the world's most perfect food." And while there is undoubtedly a time and place for everything, including convenient nutrition shakes, the devil's in the details.
So what's in these things, exactly? We shouldn't be surprised to see proteins, fats, carbs, or essential vitamins and minerals. It's the rest that can be troublesome. All too often, a substantial section of the ingredients label comprises elements that have nothing to do with health and everything to do with shelf stability, flavour, economy of production, and drink texture.
Unfortunately, the ingredients we're about to review are as potentially harmful as ubiquitous in meal replacement drink formulas. With a bit of smart shopping, you may be able to avoid the worst of the pack and find a healthier shade of liquid nutrition.
Here's a close-up look at a few of the worst offenders to avoid and two excellent components to look for.
Ingredients to Avoid
Maltodextrin Derived from starches like corn or rice, maltodextrin is a heavily processed stabilizer commonly used to add bulk and texture. While it's generally considered safe, it's hardly an inert, harmless filler. Maltodextrin is often criticized for its sky-high glycemic index. Still, in the context of meal replacement drinks, this is likely a secondary concern: the most troubling aspect is its impact on intestinal health.
More and more research indicates that maltodextrin can reduce beneficial bacteria, deplete the protective mucosal barrier, and increase gut inflammation. Maltodextrin seems to incite the growth of pathogenic bacteria linked to inflammatory and autoimmune conditions and contribute to the formation of biofilms—the slimy matrix structure that harmful bacteria use to evade the immune system. This may be why maltodextrin can even increase colitis progression in susceptible individuals. Some research indicates that it may even have adverse neurological effects.
Carrageenan This increasingly controversial thickening agent stabilizes meal replacement drinks, almond milk, plant-based ice cream, baby formula and more. Carrageenan is derived from seaweed but undergoes major chemical processing until it resembles its natural source. Carrageenan has been linked to significant digestive damage, and in animal studies, carrageenan is actually used to induce intestinal inflammation reliably.
More human studies are desperately needed, but small trials have shown that it can cause IBD flares and impaired insulin signalling. As a filler, carrageenan has zero nutritional value. Therefore, while the degree of harm may be debated, there is no downside to avoiding it altogether. While the ingredient is legal and generally regarded as safe (GRAS), more and more manufacturers have voluntarily removed it from their products anyway.
Aspartame Aspartame, the non-caloric sweetener known by various brand names like NutraSweet, Equal, and SugarTwin, is widely present in over 6,000 products, including meal replacement drinks. Despite its long-standing use, controversies persist regarding its safety, and mounting research has connected aspartame to potential harms in humans and animals, including seizures, changes in brain function, mood disorders, headaches, and disruptions to the gut microbiome.
Some studies also suggest neuro-chemical imbalances and congenital risks, raising concerns about the safety of this artificial sweetener. Although marketed as a healthier alternative to sugar, these risks question its role in products intended to support overall health. And just like maltodextrin and carrageenan, it has no nutritional value or theoretical benefit- only risk. Check out our feature Aspartame: More Bitter than Sweet for a deeper dive into aspartame.
Natural and Artificial Flavours These deceptively vague terms conceal a cocktail of chemicals that are engineered for addictive flavour, not health. Where 'natural flavours' are derived from plant or animal sources, 'artificial flavours' are entirely synthetic or derived from petroleum and other inedible origins. However, in the end, they are chemically indistinguishable from one another. They are also mysterious: where 'natural flavours' may account for one listing on an ingredient label, it can represent 100s of lab-created compounds, the vast majority of which are typically solvents, preservatives, and emulsifiers.
While flavouring elements are generally regarded as safe, there is very little oversight reviewing the thousands of different possible chemicals used in this process. As for whether or not these phantom ingredients are harmful to human health, we simply have no idea, apart from very limited evidence. However, rodent studies are not encouraging, with acute cellular toxicity and cell mutation reported in more than one.
Ingredients to Look For
Grass Fed Whey or Blended Plant-Based Protein Sources A good protein source is a great thing to look for in a meal replacement drink, and there is a case to be made that grass-fed whey protein is categorically superior to any single-source plant-based protein. While large manufacturers typically rely on pea protein as a cheap vegan option, the amino acid profile, muscle-boosting leucine content, digestibility, or absorbability don't favourably compare.
Anecdotal reports of bloating from pea protein are also not uncommon. However, for those with sensitivity to dairy or looking for plant-based options, the good news is that combinations of multiple plant-based sources can create a more well-rounded amino acid profile, affecting muscle synthesis on par with whey.
High-Quality Omega 3 Sources Omega-3s are essential fats because the body needs them but can't make them- they must come from the diet. Sadly, most people struggle to get enough of them with a standard Western diet. While most meal replacements rely on cheap, inflammatory oils like soybean or canola, intentional sources of omega-3 fatty acids can mark the difference between a good meal replacement and a bad one.
High-DHA algal oil or fish oil can contribute essential long-chain unsaturates which support brain function, switch off inflammation, and promote robust heart health. Including a clean, sustainably sourced omega-3 in a meal replacement significantly elevates its nutritional profile.
The Bottom Line
Not all meal replacements are created equal, and the ingredients above highlight just how far they can stray from principles of good health. The central problem is that mass-producing something for a consistent texture, long shelf life, and a healthy bottom line doesn't always align with nutritional priorities - indeed, it might completely oppose them. When looking for a better option, prioritize real food ingredients over synthetic fillers, flavours, and sweeteners as much as possible.
It's worth remembering that for all their marketing, most meal replacement products fall well into ultra-processed foods. And since UPFs are characterized by artificial food additives, a quick label check for the ingredients highlighted in this article can indicate whether a drink is formulated more for nourishment and health or profit and convenience.
About Soylent: Soylent ingredients. Soylent. (n.d.). https://soylent.com/pages/about-soylent
Are artificial food flavors and colorings harmful?. News. (2018, November 14). https://www.news-medical.net/health/Are-Artificial-Food-Flavors-and-Colorings-Harmful.aspx
Arnold, A. R., & Chassaing, B. (2019). Maltodextrin, Modern Stressor of the Intestinal Environment. Cellular and molecular gastroenterology and hepatology, 7(2), 475–476. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcmgh.2018.09.014
Bhattacharyya, S., Shumard, T., Xie, H., Dodda, A., Varady, K. A., Feferman, L., Halline, A. G., Goldstein, J. L., Hanauer, S. B., & Tobacman, J. K. (2017). A randomized trial of the effects of the no-carrageenan diet on ulcerative colitis disease activity. Nutrition and Healthy Aging, 4(2), 181–192. https://doi.org/10.3233/nha-170023
Brissette, C. (n.d.). Which eating habits are holding you back?. 80 Twenty Nutrition. https://80twentynutrition.com/artificial-flavors-food-avoid/
de-la-Cruz, M., Millán-Aldaco, D., Soriano-Nava, D. M., Drucker-Colín, R., & Murillo-Rodríguez, E. (2018). The artificial sweetener Splenda intake promotes changes in expression of c-Fos and NeuN in hypothalamus and hippocampus of rats. Brain research, 1700, 181–189. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brainres.2018.09.006
Does pea protein cause gas? A dietitian’s perspective. Growing Naturals. (n.d.). https://growingnaturals.com/blogs/articles/does-pea-protein-cause-gas-a-plant-based-dietitians-perspective#:~:text=Pea%20protein%20contains%20some%20Galacto,associated%20with%20gas%20and%20bloating
Dwyer, K. (2017, March 15). The truth about natural and artificial flavors. Bon Appétit. https://www.bonappetit.com/story/truth-about-natural-artificial-flavors?srsltid=AfmBOorigpPy3jno9fLf5JhdwIfPqXXy7bJeYTy1JLMSIdjsbjF8aLox
Eichel, J. (n.d.). The dangers of artificial flavors - what you need to know. WICKED Protein. https://www.wickedprotein.com/blogs/nutrition/the-dangers-of-artificial-flavors?srsltid=AfmBOoq4QyrfjYRHKKLrFH4RVQgjYxTx26fpQgrehgvIQVmH1eKQlO-S
Everything you need to know about natural flavors. Food Revolution Network. (2023, May 23). https://foodrevolution.org/blog/natural-flavors/
Feferman, L., Bhattacharyya, S., Oates, E., Haggerty, N., Wang, T., Varady, K., & Tobacman, J. K. (2020). Carrageenan-Free Diet Shows Improved Glucose Tolerance and Insulin Signaling in Prediabetes: A Randomized, Pilot Clinical Trial. Journal of diabetes research, 2020, 8267980. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8267980
Goodman M. J. (2017). The “Natural” vs. “Natural Flavors” Conflict in Food Labeling: A Regulatory Viewpoint. Food and drug law journal, 72(1), 78–102.
Imperatore, R., Orso, G., Facchiano, S., Scarano, P., Hoseinifar, S. H., Ashouri, G., Guarino, C., & Paolucci, M. (2023). Anti-inflammatory and immunostimulant effect of different timing-related administration of dietary polyphenols on intestinal inflammation in zebrafish, danio rerio. Aquaculture, 563, 738878. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2022.738878
Liebman, B., Galligan, T., Bailey, M. M., & Goldstein, Z. (2024, July 28). Artificial and natural flavoring. Center for Science in the Public Interest. https://www.cspinet.org/article/artificial-and-natural-flavoring
Mathai, J. K., Liu, Y., & Stein, H. H. (2017). Values for digestible indispensable amino acid scores (DIAAS) for some dairy and plant proteins may better describe protein quality than values calculated using the concept for protein digestibility-corrected amino acid scores (PDCAAS). The British journal of nutrition, 117(4), 490–499. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007114517000125
Martino, J. V., Van Limbergen, J., & Cahill, L. E. (2017). The Role of Carrageenan and Carboxymethylcellulose in the Development of Intestinal Inflammation. Frontiers in pediatrics, 5, 96. https://doi.org/10.3389/fped.2017.00096
Newman, T. (2024, April 23). Food flavorings: Natural, artificial, and health effects. Food Flavorings: Natural, Artificial, and Health Effects. https://zoe.com/learn/food-flavorings-safety
Nickerson, K. P., Chanin, R., & McDonald, C. (2015). Deregulation of intestinal anti-microbial defense by the dietary additive, maltodextrin. Gut microbes, 6(1), 78–83. https://doi.org/10.1080/19490976.2015.1005477
Nickerson, K. P., & McDonald, C. (2012). Crohn's disease-associated adherent-invasive Escherichia coli adhesion is enhanced by exposure to the ubiquitous dietary polysaccharide maltodextrin. PloS one, 7(12), e52132. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0052132
Oaklander, M. (2014, August 22). Soy milk brand stops using carrageenan. Time. https://time.com/3162074/carrageenan-whitewave/
Piri Damaghi, M., Mirzababaei, A., Moradi, S., Daneshzad, E., Tavakoli, A., Clark, C. C. T., & Mirzaei, K. (2022). Comparison of the effect of soya protein and whey protein on body composition: a meta-analysis of randomised clinical trials. The British journal of nutrition, 127(6), 885–895. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007114521001550
Researcher bias and the carrageenan controversy. Cornucopia Institute. (2023a, January 9). https://www.cornucopia.org/researcher-bias-carrageenan-controversy/
Sales, I. M. S., Barbosa, J. S., Silva Dos Santos, F. K., Carneiro da Silva, F. C., Ferreira, P. M. P., Marcelo de Castro E Sousa, J., & Peron, A. P. (2017). Assessment of Grape, Plum and Orange Synthetic Food Flavourings Using in vivo Acute Toxicity Tests. Food technology and biotechnology, 55(1), 131–137. https://doi.org/10.17113/ftb.55.01.17.4770
Sales, I. M. S., Silva, J. M., Moura, E. S. R., Alves, F. D. S., Silva, F. C. C., Sousa, J. M. C., & Peron, A. P. (2018). Toxicity of synthetic flavorings, nature identical and artificial, to hematopoietic tissue cells of rodents. Brazilian journal of biology = Revista brasleira de biologia, 78(2), 306–310. https://doi.org/10.1590/1519-6984.07716
VAN DER Heijden, I., Monteyne, A. J., West, S., Morton, J. P., Langan-Evans, C., Hearris, M. A., Abdelrahman, D. R., Murton, A. J., Stephens, F. B., & Wall, B. T. (2024). Plant Protein Blend Ingestion Stimulates Postexercise Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis Rates Equivalently to Whey in Resistance-Trained Adults. Medicine and science in sports and exercise, 56(8), 1467–1479. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0000000000003432
Warner J. O. (2024). Artificial food additives: hazardous to long-term health?. Archives of disease in childhood, 109(11), 882–885. https://doi.org/10.1136/archdischild-2023-326565
What’s the controversy over carrageenan? Cornucopia Institute. (2023b, January 4). https://www.cornucopia.org/carrageenan/#:~:text=Is%20carrageenan%20natural%3F,a%20highly%20processed%2C%20synthetic%20ingredient
Zangara, M. T., Ponti, A. K., Miller, N. D., Engelhart, M. J., Ahern, P. P., Sangwan, N., & McDonald, C. (2022). Maltodextrin Consumption Impairs the Intestinal Mucus Barrier and Accelerates Colitis Through Direct Actions on the Epithelium. Frontiers in immunology, 13, 841188. https://doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2022.841188
Zielinski, D. (2024a, January 2). Aspartame: More bitter than sweet · good recipes. Rily. https://www.rily.co/articles/aspartame:-more-bitter-than-sweet-48
Zielinski, D. (2024b, August 12). Ultra processed foods: Dietary demon or unjustly accused? · Good Recipes. Rily. https://www.rily.co/articles/ultra-processed-foods:-dietary-demon-or-unjustly-accused-109
Lead image credit: Alexsander Saks | Unsplash
